A Lid Alone Isn’t Enough – The Hidden Risks of Tank Neglect

This image serves as a striking example of why simply having a tank lid in place is not enough—and why routine inspection, maintenance, and hygiene controls are essential, as laid out in HSG274 Part 2.

While the cold water storage tank shown here did have a lid fitted, it had clearly been neglected for a significant period of time. The heavy accumulation of bird droppings on and around the tank is not just a sign of poor housekeeping—it is a serious red flag indicating potential contamination of the water supply. This points to failures in both pest control and water hygiene management.

Under HSG274 Part 2, it is a fundamental requirement that tanks are not only covered, but that their lids are:

  • Well-sealed and secure
  • Free from gaps that could allow ingress of insects, vermin, or debris
  • Checked at least annually as part of a planned preventative maintenance regime

In this case, the lid has done little to prevent environmental contamination. Bird faeces pose a major risk due to the pathogens they carry, and the presence of nesting materials or droppings so close to a live water system increases the likelihood of bacterial proliferation—particularly Legionella spp.

Even more concerning is that the tank remained connected to a live system, meaning water could have been drawn off at any time. Although this part of the hotel was not in current use, the system’s potential to deliver contaminated water to outlets remained, posing a risk to health and breaching fundamental principles of water safety.

Key Lessons from HSG274 Part 2

  • Inspection must be visual and thorough: Don’t just check if a lid is present—inspect for signs of contamination, pest ingress, corrosion, insulation damage, and poor installation.
  • Risk assessments must reflect actual conditions: If signs of neglect are found, the inspection frequency and level of control must be escalated immediately.
  • Storage conditions matter as much as fittings: A lid that doesn’t stop contamination is a false sense of security.

This image is more than just an example of poor practice—it’s a reminder of the potential consequences when water hygiene is deprioritised. Regular inspection in accordance with HSG274 Part 2 isn’t a box-ticking exercise—it’s a critical step in protecting public health.

Leave a Reply

Find out how we can help you!

With our extensive experience in Legionella Risk Assessment Services & Water Treatment Services Contact us today to find out how we can help you.

Contact Us

What Is BSRIA BG29 & BG50?

BG29 (Pre-Commission Cleaning of Pipework Systems) sets out best practice for cleaning commercial heating and cooling pipework before it is handed over. When new systems are installed, they contain: Mill scale from steel pipework Jointing compounds and flux residues Installation debris Construction dust and particulates If not properly removed, these contaminants: Block strainers and control… Read more »

Le Mans Crescent Project!

Major Mechanical Installation Project Underway at Le Mans Crescent, Bolton We’re proud to be delivering a significant mechanical installation project at Le Mans Crescent in Bolton, and it’s fantastic to see the works progressing well as the building services infrastructure begins to take shape on site. This phase of the project represents a key milestone… Read more »

Thermostatic Mixing Valves (TMVs): Understanding TMV2, TMV3 and Your Legal Responsibilities

Thermostatic Mixing Valves (TMVs) play a critical role in controlling water temperature and reducing the risk of scalding in both domestic and commercial buildings. In higher-risk environments such as healthcare, care homes and education settings, correct valve selection, installation and ongoing maintenance is not just best practice – it is a legal and moral responsibility…. Read more »

How Passing TMVs Drive Legionella and Biofilm Formation

Passing TMVs create the exact conditions Legionella bacteria thrive in. The combined effects include: Once temperature control is lost, biofilm rapidly develops on internal pipe surfaces. Biofilm acts as: As biofilm thickens, it further restricts flow, worsening stagnation and creating a self-reinforcing cycle that accelerates colonisation. In many investigations of persistent Legionella positives, passing TMVs… Read more »